Menu
Mar 22 - Technical Notice – No Deal Brexit - Workplace Rights in Gibraltar

Mar 22 - Technical Notice – No Deal…

The Government has publis...

Mar 22 - Young Leaders Workshops

Mar 22 - Young Leaders Workshops

Her Worship the Mayor Kai...

Mar 22 - GSD Welcomes Change To Agency Workers Qualifying Period

Mar 22 - GSD Welcomes Change To Age…

The GSD has welcomed the ...

Mar 22 - Significant Weather Warning Issued - Strong Winds Expected

Mar 22 - Significant Weather Warnin…

The Government has issued...

Mar 22 - Winners Of Short Story Competition Offered All Access Pass For Literary Festival

Mar 22 - Winners Of Short Story Com…

Gibraltar Cultural Servic...

Mar 22 - Marine Strategy Feature - Interview With Kris Kosmala

Mar 22 - Marine Strategy Feature - …

By Paul Gonzalez-Morgan ...

Mar 22 - Stephen Hermida Exhibition At Space 92 Gallery

Mar 22 - Stephen Hermida Exhibition…

Stephen Hermida, will be ...

Mar 22 - Man Arrested Following Devil’s Tower Road Crash

Mar 22 - Man Arrested Following Dev…

A 21-year-old local man w...

Mar 22 - Gibraltar Regiment Raises Over £1,000 For Regiment’s Benevolent Fund

Mar 22 - Gibraltar Regiment Raises …

The Royal Gibraltar Regim...

Mar 21 - Chief Minister’s Address To Parliament On Latest Brexit Developments

Mar 21 - Chief Minister’s Address T…

The Chief Minister delive...

Prev Next

Jul 19 - GSD Says Chief Minister “Misinformed Parliament” During Housing Act Debate

The GSD has said that a judgment of the Court of Appeal this week shows that the Chief Minister “misinformed Parliament” in a debate that led to the passing of the Housing (Amendment) Act 2013, which the Court has declared interferes with constitutional rights.

This law extended the rent control regime to a wider but limited number of tenancies. It reduced rents of these few tenants from £500 to between £100 and £150 per month, a reduction of about 70%.

A statement from the party continued: “The Judgement finds that, in the parliamentary debate, the Chief Minister:

  • said that certain provisions “should have been repealed as they were superfluous”, which contradicted an earlier finding of the Supreme Court;
  • did not explain the reason why the Government was promoting the change in the law contained in the amendment;
  • did not say why he wished to remove the difference between properties built between 1945 and 1959;
  • did not clarify why in the Government’s view the amendment was for the benefit of the public;
  • was not being accurate when he implied to Parliament that the amendment would ‘put matters right’;
  • did not explain what social policy underlay the amendment;
  • did not spell out the only effect of the amendment in manner that “a transparent democratic practice would usually require.”

“The GSD acknowledges that it supported that change in law based on the Chief Minister’s explanations. It transpires that these were inaccurate, fell short of clarification and lacking in sufficient debate.

“The GSD recognizes that Paul Balban, an affected tenant and then Minister for Housing, is said not to have participated in any decisions involving this change and to have voluntarily not taken up the reduced rent.

“While Mr Paul Balban appears properly not to have sought to take the benefit of this measure, it calls into question why the Government thought it was wise to proceed with it when it could expose itself to the very criticism that the Court of Appeal has now made to the effect that “It is worrying that one of the limited class of people who could (emphasis added) benefit from this windfall was the Minister for Housing.”

“This is pertinent when the amended law reverses the earlier decision of the Supreme Court against Mr Balban, on an Appeal from the Rent Tribunal, by which he had sought, in 2008 (before he was a Minister), to have the rent of his flat reduced to a controlled fixed rent.

“These matters are at their core about good government and as to how the Government should exercise its powers.”

Useful Links

 
www.easy.office.gi
Virtual & Physical Office Space in Gibraltar

Other Items