Menu
Dec 18 - NASUWT And Government Settle Discrepancy Between Salaries Of First And Middle School Teachers

Dec 18 - NASUWT And Government Sett…

Government of Gibraltar a...

Dec 18 - Indiya Hewkin To Represent Gibraltar Tomorrow In Grand Final Of Miss Teen International

Dec 18 - Indiya Hewkin To Represent…

Tomorrow, No1 Models Miss...

Dec 18 - Bishop Fitzgerald School Present Over £4000 To Local Charities

Dec 18 - Bishop Fitzgerald School P…

Last week Bishop Fitzgera...

Dec 18 - Marine Strategy Feature: Interview With Adolfo Utor

Dec 18 - Marine Strategy Feature: I…

By Paul Gonzalez-Morgan ...

Dec 18 - Roy Clinton Elected Member Of CIPFA

Dec 18 - Roy Clinton Elected Member…

The GSD has announced tha...

Dec 18 - Government Says GSD Is "Out Of Touch" With Reality

Dec 18 - Government Says GSD Is …

The Government says the l...

Dec 18 - GNDT Return From World Modern & Contemporary, Ballet And Jazz Dance Championships

Dec 18 - GNDT Return From World Mod…

The Gibraltar National Da...

Dec 18 - American Sociolinguist Focuses On Gibraltarian Author’s Work

Dec 18 - American Sociolinguist Foc…

Amanda Gerke, an American...

Dec 18 - Government Issues No Deal Brexit Advice On Pet Passports

Dec 18 - Government Issues No Deal …

In November, the European...

Dec 18 - GSD Says Picardo Is “Getting Nervous” About Brexit Deal Criticism

Dec 18 - GSD Says Picardo Is “Getti…

The GSD has said that the...

Prev Next

Jul 19 - Hassan Nahon: “Unclear” Housing Act Amendment Points To “Failure Of The Barristocracy”

Independent MP Marlene Hassan Nahon has said that the passing of “unclear” and “inaccurate” legislation in Parliament “spells yet another failure of the barristocracy”.

Ms Hassan Nahon argues that the judgment of the Court of Appeal regarding the passing of the amended Housing Act 2013, which declares this amendment to be unconstitutional, raises serious concerns about certain governmental practices but also about the quality of Gibraltar’s parliamentary checks and balances.

Ms Hassan Nahon said: “It must be noted that this decision is the product of an appeal from the Rent Tribunal, after a ruling from the Supreme Court in favour of Mr. Balban, who, before becoming a Minister, sought to have his rent reduced to controlled fixed rates.

“As per the court’s ruling, this legislation was passed without explaining its real intentions, without plausible justification for these intentions, without mention to social policy or the general public good and without openly disclosing the practical consequences of the amendment.

“If the Government ́s real intentions were, once again, buried under a heap of misguiding legalistic jargon, then it is either a case of incompetence or one of dishonesty. Either way it is a serious issue, and one that should not be dealt in the usual haughty, dismissive terms. The fact that Minister Balban, once a minster, chose to pay the higher rate despite having sought this amendment before being a minster, hardly remedies the corollaries of this issue. Neither does the fact that he communicated his conflict of interest while this misguiding piece of legislation was being discussed. We cannot depend on voluntary acts of good will to stop bad practices from happening. These must be enshrined in law and enforced at all levels.

“If the Government wants to really do something about the housing bubble currently affecting Gibraltar, drafting seemingly “capricious” laws affecting a handful of tenants (one of which being the Minister for Housing) is clearly not the answer. It should have brought forward a comprehensive plan to ensure access to affordable housing for all local residents.

“As for the role of the Opposition, so much for the benefits of having a ruling “barristocracy” when unsound, unjustified and deliberately vague legislation slips right under the nose of reputed lawyers and QCs, of which there were four out of seven in Opposition at the time. Surely a degree of self-criticism is in order for having voted in favour of a law with such flagrant inconsistencies.”

Useful Links

 
www.easy.office.gi
Virtual & Physical Office Space in Gibraltar

Other Items